are you a member yet
CNET NETWORKS UK CONSUMER SITES: CNET.co.uk | CNETTV.co.uk | GameSpot.co.uk | SmartPlanet.com

Anonymous User

Log in | Join us!

Advertisment
Promo

General Electric and IKEA top eco bulb tables

Energy-saving bulbs on test
Finance News Household News
Channels: Finance News, Household News Tags: energy-saving, lighting

What we've long known to be true is now official -- not all energy-saving bulbs are equal. In a test of 16 different eco lights, Which? gave first place to General Electric's Elegance T3, followed closely by IKEA and Osram.

General Electric's bulb was one of the more pricey at £3 a pop, but showed longevity well above its stated six-year life and didn't dim at all in the process. Wilkinsons is recommended as the cheapest place to get 'em. Second up, in news that will please shoppers at its blue-and-yellow boxes, was IKEA. Its Sparsam bulbs cost a more reasonable £2 and, although they dim over time, they do out-live their six-year life and produce a nice light that's the same as old skool incandescents. The bulb also scored top in the tables for start-up speed.

Chugging in at third is Osram's £2 Duluxstar, which doesn't dim much and can hack being switched on and off repeatedly -- you can buy them cheapest at Sainsbury's. Elsewhere, B&Q ranked as a miserable second-worst in the table. And if your home's an igloo, you're best off with the IKEA bulb or General Electric's Elegance GLS/CDL. They were the only two unaffected by low temperatures.

As SmartPlaneteers will know, eco bulbs might cost more up-front but they'll save you cash in the long run.Which? reckons £30 over five years, assuming you're chucking out an old 100W incandescent bulb.

Posted: 30 October 2007, 03:17pm by Adam Vaughan
Share this article:
DIGGDigg this story StumbleUponStumble this story

Related Links

Repairs are up 7.5 per cent, but which brands are the most repair-friendly?
Dragons' Den plastic bag bin hits shops
Top 10 reusable bags, Cath Kidston included
Avatar

Urban Badger 31 October 2007 09:37am

I appreciate that the longevity, price and start up speed are all important, but my major bugbear is the luminosity. The eco-bulb I have are all dimmer than their comparable incandescent bulb cousins, even though the packaging labels them as 100w,60w,etc. equivalent. What is the maximum strength eco bulb you can get and how does this compare?




Anonymous User
To post with your own avatar and username, please log in or register
Add your comment here
Email Address
Information Please note: Your email address must be entered but will not be displayed
Confirm Email Address


Information Please note: All submitted content becomes the sole property of CNET Networks UK and may be used, edited or rejected at CNET Networks UK's sole discretion. You acknowledge that you, not CNET Networks UK, are responsible for the contents of your submission.





Get SmartPlanet in your inbox

Get SmartPlanet in your inbox

Step this way to get your daily fix of green news, eco product launches and videos delivered by email.

Advertisment


Pinnacle Journey 1.0 2008
Cheap and cheerful -- the Journey hits the value bullseye. And doesn't end up a horrible compromise in doing so.
Mezzo d-10
Too costly, particularly compared to its d-9 sibling. But despite that, this is the state-of-the-art for folding bikes -- fast, light, practical.
Puma Glow Rider
The emperor's new bicycle -- all marketing and no trousers. Over-expensive, handles and folds poorly, doesn't glow well enough, and is stealable despite the weird cable-cum-downtube.
Weleda Edelweiss Sun Lotion SPF 15
It's a very good, honest sun lotion and we appreciate that -- we're excited about Weleda as a company, but not overly so about this particular product
LG 32LG5000
Stylish and with good performance, this is a nice TV, especially at just over £400 -- but the high energy use is a turn off


Copyright ©1995-2008 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved.