Should football players ditch the helmets in the name of concussions?

By Larry Dignan | Nov 11, 2009 |

Concussions have been a huge issue for the National Football League and football players and much of the focus revolves around helmets. Is it time to get rid of helmets completely?

This idea, which would be considered blasphemy in many parts, was raised by The Wall Street Journal. The gist: If football players didn’t wear helmets they wouldn’t hit with their heads. If they didn’t hit with their heads the concussion rate would slow.

The money quote:

“Some people have advocated for years to take the helmet off, take the face mask off. That’ll change the game dramatically,” says Fred Mueller, a University of North Carolina professor who studies head injuries. “Maybe that’s better than brain damage.”

There’s something to that. I’ve played football and have had a bunch of concussions. I’ve also played rugby. What you learn quickly is that you have to unlearn the way you hit when you transition from football to rugby. Simply put, your face and forehead aren’t the lead weapon (in most cases).

The Journal notes that the NFL isn’t considering removing helmets from the game. Indeed, the lack of helmets would dramatically change the game. The collisions and violence are why we watch.

Knowing that the NFL is focusing on better helmets and rule changes. What’s unclear is whether new technology can limit long -term damage to players. And what the NFL ultimately decides has big ramifications for all of those college and high school football players getting knocked in the head.

Also: NFL players as guinea pigs

 
Reply to Story

SmartPlanet TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via RSS

  •  
    1

    Joe McKendrick

    11/11/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Should football players ditch the helmets in the name of concussions?

    Parallel theory about auto safety: Some say that the more cars are loaded up with safety equipment (air bags, bumpers, etc.), the more recklessly people will drive. Greater consequences instill greater control. (I'd rather stick with the air bags, however...)

  •  
    2

    shanedr

    11/12/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Should football players ditch the helmets in the name of concussions?

    Right! Hitting your head on the inside of a helmet is much more
    damaging then hitting your head on the ground or whatever.

    What is amazing are people who even take the concept seriously.

    For those with zero common sense let me inform you that hitting a
    padded object is much less damaging then hitting an unpadded object.

  •  
    3

    andrewclient

    11/16/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Should football players ditch the helmets in the name of concussions?

    Ya You can get better from www.yanksguide.com which provides more information on how the game goes and what are the essentails needed.
    Visit www.yanksguide.com for more information.

The following tags are supported in Smartplanet comments:
<b></b> <i></i> <u></u> <pre></pre>

Leave a Reply

  1. Name: You are currently: a Guest |
advertisement

Quick Poll

advertisement

Larry Dignan

Larry Dignan is Editor in Chief of ZDNet and SmartPlanet as well as Editorial Director of ZDNet's sister site TechRepublic. He was most recently Executive Editor of News and Blogs at ZDNet. Prior to that he was executive news editor at eWeek and news editor at Baseline. He also served as the East Coast news editor and finance editor at CNET News.com. Larry has covered the technology and financial services industry since 1995, publishing articles in WallStreetWeek.com, Inter@ctive Week, The New York Times, and Financial Planning magazine. He's a graduate of the Columbia School of Journalism and the University of Delaware.

For daily updates, follow Larry on Twitter.

Larry Dignan

Larry Dignan has nothing to disclose. He doesn't hold investments in the technology companies he covers.

Andrew Nusca

Andrew J. Nusca is an associate editor for ZDNet and SmartPlanet. As a journalist based in New York City, he has written for Popular Mechanics and Men's Vogue and his byline has appeared in New York magazine, The Huffington Post, New York Daily News, Editor & Publisher, New York Press and many others. He also writes The Editorialiste, a media criticism blog.

He is a New York University graduate and former news editor and columnist of the Washington Square News. He is a graduate of the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism. He has been named "Howard Kurtz, Jr." by film critic John Lichman despite having no relation to him. A native of Philadelphia, he lives in New York with his fiancée and his cat, Spats.

Follow him on Twitter

Andrew Nusca

Andrew J. Nusca does not hold any investments in the technology companies he covers.
Smart Takes is a regular digest of the day's news headlines viewed through a SmartPlanet lens, offering an editor's take on breaking stories and opinion from around the Web and highlighting information that will make you smarter.