Follow this blog:
RSS

Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe

By | March 23, 2011, 8:18 AM PDT

The Federal Transit Authority has proposed to raise the assumed average weight of a bus commuter around the United States to accommodate the increasing waistline of most Americans. The federal agency wants to raise the assumed average weight per bus passenger from 150 pounds to 175 pounds, which could mean fewer people will be allowed to board city buses to meet safety regulations.

The authority has also proposed to add an extra quarter of a square foot of floor space per passenger on buses. With several passengers weighing far more than 200 pounds, the new system seems slightly more realistic.

Currently, the average weight for a U.S. male is 194.7 pounds and 164.7 pounds for women, according to the Centers for Disease Control. The federal guidelines, however, were based on surveys done in 1960-62.

The FTA’s new assumed weight average for city buses, is still less then the average for passengers used by the Coast Guard or the Federal Aviation Administration.

The Federal Aviation Administration, which handles airline travel, assumes the average passenger weight at 190 pounds in the summer and 195 pounds in the winter, while the Coast Guard puts the average weight at 185 pounds for boats and ferries.

Even ambulances around the country have begun to expand to keep up with the weight of the patients riding in them. Boston recently spent over $12,000 per ambulance to accommodate more obese passengers. Similarly, Fort Worth, Texas, has spent $7,000 per vehicle.

The changes come as an increasing number of Americans are taking to public transportation because of high fuel prices. An American Public Transportation Association study predicts that $5 gallon gas could add 1.5 billion trips on the U.S. public transportation system.

Leading bus manufacturers, including Daimler AG and Volvo, said they may choose to upgrade their buses to carry more weight. The vehicle upgrades could cost about $25,000, however.

While realigning transit to fit its passenger base makes sense, over a third of Americans are currently obese, and that’s a trend we need to reverse.

Via USA Today

Start your week smarter with our weekly e-mail newsletter. It's your cheat sheet for good ideas. Get it.

Ami Cholia

About Ami Cholia

Ami Cholia was a contributing editor for SmartPlanet in 2011.

Ami Cholia

Ami Cholia

Contributing Editor, Transportation

Ami Cholia has written for AltTransport, Inhabitat, The Huffington Post and Sunday Mid Day in India. She holds degrees from the University of Texas at Austin and the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism. She is based in New York.

Follow her on Twitter.

Ami Cholia

Ami Cholia

Ami does not have financial holdings that would influence how or what she covers.

She writes for SmartPlanet and is not an employee of CBS.

If you liked this, don't miss...
17
Comments

Join the conversation!

Follow via:
RSS
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
How about the nation makes an effort to make it harder for
overweight people to stay overweight instead of catering to a
weight-stricken population? Doing these things only tell
Americans that it's a-okay to risk your health due to gluttony.
Sure not every person who is obese has eaten themselves to this
point, but that's the vast minority (a miniscule fraction, actually) of
the people who are like this.

I wish the authorities would stop making it alright for people to live
in physical risk just so their feelings won't get hurt. What about
the rest of your body? Their feelings are only hurt all the time due
to insecurity, and half of that insecurity is due to being obese! It's
a vicious cycle that just has to be cut because right now America
is on one hell of a slippery slope.

Instead of spending money expanding bus seats, office chairs
and Tare levels of 18-wheelers, spend that money on farming
subsidees and make it harder to ignore healthy food. Take away
their excuses of only being able to afford 99cent meals, and
make exercise parks more available and secure for citizens, and
you will see a nationwide change for the better instead.

Excellent article, but at the same time such a disheartening,
frustrating one.
Posted by Chronological
23rd Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
If we are truly concerned about weight (and we should be), how
about finding a way to loose weight that *keeps* the lost pounds
off afterwards?

Most overweight people *did* try diets and switching to healthier
menus; they might be on one right now. The problem is, after a
temporary success (shown in weight loss advertises) the pounds
always come back, even though one still follows the regime. (The
part the advertises don't talk about.)

I'm as willing to follow a working permanent weight loss solution
as the next guy; as soon as there will be one.
Posted by mrdelurk@...
23rd Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
@ ctJemm - Everybody gets to go to hell in their own way.

I myself am at 235 lbs. My claculated BMI says I'm obese. I would submit that an obese person does not sink to the bottom of the pool when they stop treading water. One of the reasons the BMI is bogus. The BMi says I should weigh less than I did in High School when I was running cross country.
Posted by zclayton3
23rd Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
mrdelurk@ There is a reliable diet which works. I know because I
use it. The secret is simply eat less.
Posted by misceng
23rd Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
@ ctJemm
Are you joking? You want the goverment to step in and tell people what they can and con not eat, talk about a scoialist goverment if I ever heard of one.
I don't agree with the giverment spending money, but I am sure there is a better way. Like educating people, or enforcing these resturant to let people know whats really in thier food.
Posted by jpyles
23rd Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
I don't think it is simply a matter of eating less. There is a
psychological reason why people eat more, even when their body
doesn't need it. The subconscious mind tells the body to store fat
for the lean times ahead. In the pre-historic days the stresses
that triggered the extra eating tended to be physical, seasonal
climactic changes etc. Nowadays we still have stresses but they
tend to be mental. So now we have stresses that tell our bodies
we are needing to increase fat for the future but we don't have
jobs that are physical enough to use up some of the energy we
have stored. If you simply stop eating your sub-concious believes
you are starving and instructs you to eat more.

You need to address the psychological concerns in order to stop
the body from eating more than it needs. You can no more tell a
fat person to lose weight by eating less than you can tell a person
suffering from clinical depression to "snap out of it", or a
schizophrenic "dump" their buddies.

You need to convince the sub-concious that there is no danger in
being thin - despite all the threats of looming recession and
unemployment (or possibilities of earthquakes). wink
Posted by greggatshack
23rd Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
man, maybe this is why we have weight problems...everybody seems to think they know something about eating healthy and losing weight, but when they open their mouths and share it it's just pure garbage... "just eat less"..."your subconscious is causing you to eat more to plan for lean times ahead"...seriously? LOL. Please learn something about metabolism, the contents of the foods we eat, exercise etc...THEN come back and try to give some advice.

Seriously though- NOBODY is making life decisions on their health based on what bus regulation changes have gone through... that argument about this change just enabling people to stay unhealthy is completely ridiculous. Yes, we do need to get behind policies and initiatives that motivate people to lead healthy lives, but the fact is that buses, elevators and all these other things NEED to be safe, so if the data suggests the 'average' weight of Americans has gone up, we need to account for that to keep things safe.

They are two totally different problems to solve, it would make no sense to lump them into one... like fat people are going to say "oh no, the transit authority isn't going to raise it's 'average weight' value?! Man, I guess I'll have to start losing weight!" lol, come on...
Posted by thisnameisok
23rd Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
@zclayton3

Yeah the BMI is a crock of fat! I play basketball with the guys twice a week and we usually run full court for 2 1/2 to 3 hours. I beat the skinny guys down the court every time and at the end of the night, I'm always the one calling for just one more game. I occaisionally go home and do another 1-2 hours of another intense physical activity after. According to my BMI, I'm morbidly obese.

Back in college when my daily routine included a 3mi run, 20mins on the bike, weightlifting, and basketball. Back then I could dunk the ball, but I was easily obese according to the BMI.
Posted by jeverettk
24th Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
194 lb on a male is obese?

Yes, so the average weight of an american is rising.

But isn't the average height also rising?

BMI is a crock of BS. It does a poor job at adjusting for muscle. According to BMI, pretty much anyone in good shape, with muscle tone is overweight. When did anorexic become the ideal body type?

This just makes me think the so called "scientists" who do these studies don't really have a clue what they are talking about.
Posted by keitha73
24th Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
I think they use BF% as well. I guess it depends on who is doing the experiments, but in general everyone knows BMI by itself is a poor measurement of healthy body weight...
as far as the bus thing is concerned, it doesn't really matter...whether people are getting heavier but are at a healthy weight (i.e. heavier but taller), or are getting heavier and are overweight- the average weight has still gone up, so any safety calculations should account for that.
Posted by thisnameisok
24th Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
Ketha73, no the average American is not any taller than in the
1970s. If anything we are a tad shorter. If you don't count the
Asian and Hispanic population, we might be a tad taller, but. . .

For very muscular, athletic people, BMI doesn't work very well.

The Army has a better scheme which incorporates measurements
besides height. They have to, 'cause they impose penalties for
being overweight, and need to allow for desirable outliers which
the simple BMI formula does not.

Doctors have been measuring the height and weighing people for
ages, so the least mortality statistics based on height and weight
are very good, to say the least.

Now the question we don't know the answer to is, "Is a high BMI a
risk factor for those who aren't fat?"

As for me, I have a BMI of about 20, but I'm a bit of a mouse
potato, so I am carying around a bit of a spare tire despite a BMI
well in the "normal" range.

As for affecting the safety of city busses, Around here it doesn't
make a bit of difference 'cause I've never seen one even half full.
Posted by CodeCurmudgeon
24th Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
I am amazed that the average is not significantly higher.
Posted by IMWeira
25th Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
It's not about going on 'diets', or counting calories, or extreme
willpower to try to eat less. The answer is simply eating good,
healthy food. This means mostly plants, not processed.

Read "In Defense of Food", or "The China Study", and I don't think
anyone will stay obese.
Posted by Richard Darling
28th Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
Which cities are having problems?
Which cities are having problems with too many overweight passengers?
Not my town.
There's not enough ridership to justify most of the routes without city subsidies.
Posted by llamasaki
30th Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
Ever notice how obese people deny that they're obese? That's the problem. Got denial? Obesity is caused by overeating, gluttony.
Posted by ITOdeed
1st Apr 2011
0 Votes
+ -
CrystalT -- #1
"How about the nation makes an effort to make it harder for
overweight people to stay overweight instead of catering..."

How about minding your own damned business?
Posted by Rodo1
1st Apr 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Overweight Americans are making city buses unsafe
Unrealistic assumptions make bus unsafe. Duh
Posted by Altotus
1st Apr 2011
Join the conversation
Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]

Join the SmartPlanet community and join the conversation! Signing up is fast and free. Don't wait -- we want to hear your opinion!