Follow this blog:
RSS

In Hawaii, plastic bag fee gains support

By | February 19, 2012, 1:14 PM PST

hawaii-plastic-bag-fee_n_1284296.html.jpg

Hawaii is proposing a bill that collects a fee from customers who choose disposable paper and plastic shopping bags, the HuffPost Green reports.

The bill, House Bill 2260, is gaining support and is working its way through Hawaii’s legislature. If the bill pass the house, Hawaii will become the first state to enact this type of pro-environment legislation.

Advocates of the bill say that the average person uses 400 plastic bags per year and they’re hoping that charging 5 cents per bag will discourage people from using single-use shopping bags.They note that the bags require fossil fuels for manufacture, harm marine life when it ends up in the ocean, burden overcrowded landfills and end up as unsightly litter.

Mark Fox, the Director of External Affairs for Nature Conservancy, told the House committee on Thursday that he hopes the bill will work on changing people’s behavior and encourage them to use reusable bags. He further notes that for the ones who are unable to change their behavior it will contribute to helping the watersheds.

Sixty to 70 percent of the collected fees will go into the natural area reserve fund for watershed protection, restoration and reacquisition. Right now, only 10 percent of the watershed is protected, Guy Kaulukuki, the deputy director of the state Department of Land and Natural Resources said, and it has taken 40 years to get there.

Several grocery store chains, such as Safeway and Times Supermarket, support the bill but request that the state use some of  the fee to help them cover the cost of administering the program. Carol Pergill, the president of the Retail Merchants of Hawaii, noted that the proposal puts a burden on consumers rather that businesses.

Stuart Coleman, from the Surfrider Foundation, told the committee that the bill is a win-win for everyone. ” We’ve got businesses behind us. we’ve got government agencies. We’ve got environmental groups and just a whole wide array of school groups and citizens groups and such. It’s very inspiring to see everything coming together.”

Start your week smarter with our weekly e-mail newsletter. It's your cheat sheet for good ideas. Get it.

Ina Damm Muri

About Ina Damm Muri

Ina Damm Muri is a weekend editor for SmartPlanet.

Ina Damm Muri

Ina Damm Muri

Weekend Editor

Ina Damm Muri is a multimedia journalist based in New York. Previously, she worked at Aspen Magazine, CBS4 Denver and the Daily Camera in Boulder. She holds two degrees from the University of Colorado at Boulder.

Follow her on Twitter.

Ina Damm Muri

Ina Damm Muri

Ina Damm Muri does not have financial holdings that would influence how or what she covers.

She writes for SmartPlanet and is not an employee of CBS.

If you liked this, don't miss...
6
Comments

Join the conversation!

Follow via:
RSS
+2 Votes
+ -
Great Idea!
We don't have that here in the Philippines, but when I took a trip to Hong Kong, the convenience stores/grocery stores I went to charged a fee for every plastic bag used (basically you bought the plastic bag). I had to make a quick trip to the store so I forgot my reusable shopping bag. I ashamedly shelled out a few bucks to get a plastic bag for my items. Not surprisingly, I was the only one with a plastic bag; everyone else had reusables. It just goes to show that people will follow, as long as you hit them where it hurts: the pocket.

Juan Miguel Ruiz (Going Green)
http://www.GreenJoyment.com
Posted by Green Joy
20th Feb
-3 Votes
+ -
Who wants to carry around a lot of fabric bags?
I do my grocery shopping once a week. Usually that requires 8 or so bags to hold all my groceries. Carrying that many bags into the store and storing them in my cart as I shop (where they take up space in an already full cart by the time I check out) would be a major hassle. I could go to the store more than once a week, but I would easily eat up any savings from plastic bags in gasoline.

400 bags per year is about 4.4 pounds. That's 1% to 1.5% of a barrel of oil Given how much petroleum products we all consume in gasoline, heating oil, jet fuel, other plastics, etc., it's a very negligible savings.

It's true that improperly disposed of bags do get into the ocean. But many of us live far from the ocean where the bags will never get into the waterways. People who live near the ocean would probably spend less time making sure their plastic bags are properly disposed of rather than constantly dealing with the hassle of reusable bags.

In the overall scheme of things, plastic grocery bags are not a major cause of global warming or environmental pollution when compared with other uses of petrochemicals. This is just another case of people who get emotionally involved without actually doing the numbers. Why should we let such people run our lives???
Posted by zackers
20th Feb
+3 Votes
+ -
Excuses
I have 5 reuseable grocery bags. I just fold up and carry 4 of them inside the other one to the store. The whole package is about an inch thick. It's no big deal.
Posted by riverat1
20th Feb
-3 Votes
+ -
plastic bags
I re-use plastic bags to collect household waste from individual bins at home. Anyway, what about melting the bags and making various products, or, melt, then grind the plastic into sand? Just mix it into soil, and use as an inert growing medium.
Posted by kitemanmusic
20th Feb
-3 Votes
+ -
More taxation without representation
If enacted into law, this would force shoppers of all ages, whether Hawaiian or not, to have to pay for bags that were free of the equivalent of a tax before. This decision would be made by the voting portion of just the 76 people who represent only the population of the state. Also, the fee would not be deductible like state sales tax for federal personal income tax purposes.
Posted by meniskos@...
20th Feb
+3 Votes
+ -
What whiners
We have had that fee for over 30 years.

You who are against such fees, think for a moment how many plastic bags are used and discarded each year. How many do You think it is? 10000? 5 million? Try 500,000,000,000. That's right! Shame on You who claim that it's "not a major cause of global warming or environmental pollution". Really? And Santa Claus is real too?

@zackers: lazy, lazy, lazy...Have You ever even TRIED using reusable shopping bags? Here's a tip: You can put an empty bag.... wait for it.....inside another empty bag. In fact, You can put all eight bags inside one of them. No hassle, no problem.

@meniskos: Why on earth do You think You should be able to deduct the fee? You are wasting nonrenewable resources, of course You must pay for it just like everybody else. There's no such thing as a 'free lunch'.
Posted by Dukhalion
Updated - 21st Feb
Join the conversation
Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]

Join the SmartPlanet community and join the conversation! Signing up is fast and free. Don't wait -- we want to hear your opinion!