Follow this blog:
RSS

Apple rejects ‘questionable’ US drone strike tracker app

By | September 3, 2012, 2:00 AM PDT

Apple’s app store has removed an application which allows users to track U.S. military drone strikes for ‘questionable content’.

After the British newspaper The Guardian ran an interactive map of American drone strikes earlier this month, which pinpointed the locations in Pakistan where missiles from unmanned aerial vehicles struck suspected terrorist bases, New York University student Josh Begley took the data to develop an iPhone app.

Begley’s app, called Drone+, was dedicated exclusively to tracking drone strikes. Every time a drone strike occurred, an alert was sent to the user, and location could be tracked through an interactive map.

In the first instance, Apple rejected the app for being “not useful”. Begley then added the drone alert feature — and it was rejected for the second time due to Google’s logo placed on the map. The third time, the application was rejected for being “objectionable and crude”.

This week, Apple notified the app developer that the software represents “excessively crude” content, even though there is no graphic images or close-ups and no pornography — it showed nothing more than the pinpoint location of a drone strike on a map.

“I wanted to have a more granular sense of what drone strikes really did look like out of genuine curiosity.” Begley told the New York Times.

Apple spokesman Tom Neumayr confirmed that the app was removed for violating Apple policy, but refused to comment on what content was deemed ‘objectionable’.

However, the puzzling aspect is this — why was the material available through The Guardian’s app — “nearly identical” as the New York Times reports — acceptable, whereas an individual’s app was not?

Begley wanted the app to drive users into “drone-consciousness” — to show how military technology is being deployed across the East. He said:

“I didn’t actually expect anyone to download the app. People don’t want to hear about drone strikes But that’s kind of the point. Even if we have access to the data, do we really care to be interrupted by it?”

Start your week smarter with our weekly e-mail newsletter. It's your cheat sheet for good ideas. Get it.

Charlie Osborne

About Charlie Osborne

Charlie Osborne is a contributing editor for SmartPlanet.

Charlie Osborne

Charlie Osborne

Contributing Editor

Charlie Osborne is a freelance journalist and graphic designer based in London. In addition to SmartPlanet, she also writes the iGeneration column for business technology website ZDNet. She holds degrees in medical anthropology from the University of Kent.

Follow her on Twitter.

Charlie Osborne

Charlie Osborne

Charlie Osborne does not have financial holdings that would influence how or what she covers.

She writes for SmartPlanet and is not an employee of CBS.

If you liked this, don't miss...
22
Comments

Join the conversation!

Follow via:
RSS
+4 Votes
+ -
Apple rejects drone app
Now that Apple has rejected it, you can be sure that it will not go away. Developers are likely doing one for Android, Linux, and Windows 8. BTW, We need an app that ranks politicians according to the number of times they tell a whopper. Call it Pinocchio's Nose.
Posted by oceanpine@...
3rd Sep
0 Votes
+ -
You'll notice...
You'll notice who is made out to be the bad guy here, really it's the little man who tried to put a new product out there for the public to use if and when they like. Apple, under the BIG direction of BIG government directive tries to yet stifle out one more freedom, that of free enterprise. What next?
Posted by Cyclingmasterseller
7th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
pinocchion app a hit and depressing
I like the politician one even more.
Posted by Kiljoy616
7th Sep
+2 Votes
+ -
Apple rejects drone app
So Apple has joined the Main stream media
As George Carlin put it. "Unpaid PR for the US military"
Just because Apple Censors out controversial drone attacks doesn't mean they will just go away
Posted by csumbler
3rd Sep
0 Votes
+ -
Big Brother
Big Brother at work censoring and falsfaying information. The propaganda machine controls what we see and hear!
Posted by acyron
3rd Sep
0 Votes
+ -
Amen
Amen. Pretty clear to see, at least for those of us who still think for ourselves.
Posted by Cyclingmasterseller
7th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
No you did not
No big brother here, but more like Little Brother which to me is even more scarier. Corp. dictating what is right and wrong what next Corp are people to oh wait that already has happen. Never mind!
Posted by Kiljoy616
7th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
APPLE = IBM
When Apple became the largest corporation in the US, it started acting like it - knock down anything that even might be construed as dissent. In 2012, Big Brother lives in Cupertino.
Posted by northca707@...
3rd Sep
0 Votes
+ -
APPLE is not the biggest corp. who told you that.
Close but no yet.

Reality check http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune500/2012/snapshots/387.html
Number 1 is Exxon Mobil

Actually a lot of oil companies are on top. Apple is up there surpassed MS years ago go figure but MS still owns most people ass.

Apple is 17 don't get me wrong that is high up, way over IBM and yes
Posted by Kiljoy616
7th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
Uuummmm
This is for 2011 dude. While you were sleeping, Apple became #1
Posted by Gr8Music
7th Sep
+1 Vote
+ -
APPLE = A-pple P-eople P-romoting L-arge E-vil
The drone app has steep "redeeming social value." Apple is full of themselves. We didn't hear Apple make changes at their Foxcon factory in China with abused workers commiting suicide calling it "crude and objectionable." It took a third party to blow the whistle....just like Josh Begley's app Drone+

The farce here is that Apple is now acting as a kind of social Drone taking out apps they self-righteously finger as "crude and objectionable."

Morally troubling..............
Posted by SmartPlanetORelse
Updated - 3rd Sep
-3 Votes
+ -
The Haughty on a Harsh Road
Excuuuuuse me, but if I am paying for an internet phone, I reserve the right to run my choice of programs (you call them apps) on it. Since when has a smartphone manufaturer been promoted to Nanny-in-Chief? Drone strikes are valid news.

What about kind persons who want to use the program to specifically pray for those killed or injured at the strike locations? As in, add them to prayers for all who are killed in wars every day? There are many nice people who pray daily for those killed in violence, and they frequently gather up names and places, to mention in the prayers.

No, Apple does not want to help 'those' people to be prayed for.

If they are the enemy and it's war then kill'em, yes that's a hard/harsh one but it has to be done. - but once they're gone, it's no wrong and no treason to say a word for their souls, which is what every free man has a right to. Apple, you rob the dead.

That's harsh.
Posted by opcom
4th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
one point further...
One point further, and that is this: The Federal Government needs to stay the hell out of our lives, and this includes Apple, Google, whatever, whomever. Shows you how this government has sunk to new lows ever since obama stole office. And what is obama still doing in Afgan? One clearly has to look into the motive(s) of Apple, and who Apple associates with. Amen.
Posted by Cyclingmasterseller
7th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
Re: One point further
And you think Romney would be any different? The military industrial complex runs the military my friend. You have wars every now and then to use up weapons stockpiles so the military, i.e. government has to procure more and keep the weapons makers in business..
Posted by misterd2081@...
8th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
I'm Confused by the Comments
Who exactly owns the App Store and sets the rules? {Apple} Why is the App Store wildly popular with developers? {They make a lot of money} Why can Apple kill this app? {Because they can} What can Josh Begley do? {Anything he wants except offer the app on the App Store}

I'm sure that the people that don't get it, don't live in America - that's just the way we roll.
Posted by Gr8Music
7th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
Sounds like......
To me it sounds like Google and the US government are in bed with each other.

Funny, the US government finds nothing wrong with tracking the poor with the free hand-out track phones they give (almost shove) to those on Medicaid or low income, yet they're afraid that someone can get a close look into where drone strikes occur in the middle east? Uncle Sam is way too overly cautious I would say.

The US Government doesn't even want the common man to know where DUI checkpoints are at -- even if the common non-drinker wants to avoid check point charlie.

Sounds like I need to live in another country soon, a free one.
Posted by Cyclingmasterseller
7th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
Apple spokesman Tom Neumayr lied
The fact is, the app is not objectionable in any way, shape, or form; and does not violate Apple policy.

Considering that a nearly identical app is available through The Guardian, it is plain that Apple is deliberately defrauding Begley in favor of a large corporation.
Posted by Dr_Zinj
7th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
Apple getting into dictating what is...
They objected to what? To many bombs dropped by US drones or that its to much information for citizens to know.
Posted by Kiljoy616
7th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
Apple Drone Strikes app
Very critical to keep murder secret. Especially when ( it is found necessary to take out the target's family ) or loose the opportunity.
Posted by JoseJavaho48
Updated - 7th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
Apple Drone Strikes app
$ can buy almost anything, excluding your soul.
Posted by JoseJavaho48
7th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
Apple nice app
So The apple company has signed up with the Main flow media
As Henry Carlin put it. "Unpaid PR for the US military"
Just because The apple company Censors out questionable drone strikes doesn't mean they will just go away.
Source:
http://goodtechsystems.com/drones-to-be-become-weather-chasers-natural-disaster-hunters/
Posted by grantatrade2012
9th Sep
0 Votes
+ -
How about an app
How about an app that tracks the drones in England

My Site:http://www.macmediatool.com/
Posted by Elliesky
4th Jan
Join the conversation
Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]

Join the SmartPlanet community and join the conversation! Signing up is fast and free. Don't wait -- we want to hear your opinion!