Rethinking Healthcare

Men get breast cancer too and what that means for screening

Men get breast cancer too and what that means for screening

Posting in Cancer

Our risks of disease are unique to each of us. Some are environmental, like exposure to toxins. But many are also genetic, as in the case of a North Carolina man denied a test for breast cancer. Both his parents died of it, and it should have been given.

The denial of a free breast cancer screening to 45-year old Scott Cunningham has highlighted a key fact of our time.

Men get breast cancer too.

(Picture from the CBS Early Show.)

It's not nearly as common in men as in women. There are 100 cases of breast cancer in women for every one in a man. But Cunningham's case was unique. Both his parents, his father as well as his mother, had died of the disease. And he was having symptoms.

(The best-known male breast cancer sufferer so far? KISS drummer Peter Criss (the one whose make-up is that of a cat), 63. Male breast cancer often comes later in life,

The CDC, looking at the gross numbers, defends the idea of screening only women, but even that refusal reveals a truth the agency would likely want everyone to know.

Our risks of disease are unique to each of us. Some are environmental, like exposure to toxins. But many are also genetic, as in Cunningham's case.

You don't need a genetic screening to estimate your risk, although it can help. But a complete health record, including data on past screenings and tests, can also help.

The move toward electronic health records is vital in this regard. In some cases, like breast cancer, population studies show we are over-diagnosing and over-treating. There is also a radiation load from CT scans and other tests that can itself raise risks.

All these questions respond to data, and getting better data is the point of the current health IT revolution. Data will tell us some people need more tests, and some need fewer. Data will let us balance risks and rewards. Data will save lives, even while data saves money.

Screenings represent data, but they are just one type of data. Risk data from your life is data (Cunningham's picture indicates he may be at risk for skin cancer). Genetic data is also vital.

Don't cry privacy. Get the data. Save your life.

Share this

Dana Blankenhorn

Contributing Editor

Contributing Editor Dana Blankenhorn has written for the Chicago Tribune, Advertising Age's "NetMarketing" supplement and founded the Interactive Age Daily for CMP Media. He holds degrees from Rice and Northwestern universities. He is based in Atlanta. Follow him on Twitter. Disclosure