Follow this blog:
RSS

Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care

By | February 16, 2010, 4:00 AM PST

Patch Adams testifying on Capitol Hill in 2009

Patch Adams testifying on Capitol Hill in 2009

It’s been a dozen years since the world learned of Patch Adams, in the movie Patch Adams, starring Robin Williams. I haven’t seen it, but I learned last week that the real Adams is anything but Hollywood.

Founder of the Gesundheit Institute in rural West Virginia, Adams is on a life mission to change the way health care is given, received and valued. After treating 15,000 patients in its first 12 years (all at no cost to the patients), the institute started the next phase of Adams’ vision, building a full-scale model of his dream hospital—where compassion and intimacy replace malpractice insurance; and fun and silliness quash liability waivers. Patients will pay nothing and staff will make next to nothing, but caregiver burnout and third-party insurance will be nonexistent, and there will be joy.

Adams continues raising money for his teaching center and clinic, while lecturing around the world about the need for a drastic change in health care. He testified on Capitol Hill last year (see video here). We spoke on the phone one evening last week.

In your speeches, you talk about modeling creative problem-solving to improve health care. How do you suggest people start thinking more creatively?

How do we get people to think? We’re so far away from thinking. I suspect that less than 10 percent of our nation thinks. In the same way we use our hands to cook and eat, but to use our hands to play the piano—that’s different. It’s best to have a system that trains out thinking—thinking being dangerous to the paradigm.

That sounds grim.

Have you not had the same thoughts? People regurgitate things they hear, like “terrorist” or “socialism.” They’re doing so little thinking, they’re actually arguing against the thing they need. How is it that in a country whose documents talk about “of the people, by the people, for the people,” that we are the only industrialized nation in the world that doesn’t have a health care system that takes care of its people? It’s inconceivable.

In this meaningless health care bill, we come up with a plan where people have to pay into insurance companies. The [administrative costs] to insurance companies is 30 percent. If it were a single-payer system that would be dramatically different. There hasn’t been a positive book or article in 40 years on the way we deliver health care. I have a huge library on the ways we criticize health care, but nothing positive. One doesn’t have to be a scholar to ask what is wrong with this picture.

What can we do?

When you ask what can we do to have people think about these issues, my response is that people are more interested in professional sports than thy are in any social, political or environmental issue. The Super Bowl—multimillionaires playing with their balls–is interesting. But 11 million Americans going to bed hungry is not interesting. The fact that the Patriot Act broke six of the 10 Bill of Rights, that’s not interesting.

That’s why I’ve stuck to my model, which is entering its 40th year. Without a model, we don’t think something can be done. If we had a hospital model at only 10 percent of the cost, that would shape things. We can certainly show other countries’ models, that caring for people at much cheaper rates is possible.

What’s your philosophy behind bringing fun and play into health care?

In health care reform, all they talk about is cost. They don’t talk about how burnout is epidemic everywhere in the world. If we require our staff to be happy, loving, creative and thoughtful, we can create an atmosphere where it’s fun to be a caregiver and fun to be a patient. As Mary Poppins said, “In every job that must be done, there is an element of fun.”

Our injecting love and fun in our practice is because we don’t want to give out psychotropic medications, but rather, show that life is a celebration. It’s a glorious thing to be alive. How can we get a surgeon to work for $300 a month and the clearing person to work for $300 month, and thousands of people are applying? The surgeon will trade $2 million a year to have their family living a life of fun and love. The problem is, most people are lonely, bored and frightened. Two books I’m trying to get people to read are Loneliness by John Cacioppo and The Loss of Happiness in Market Democracies by Robert Lane.

What are you reading now?

Just as you called– Schools for Growth: Radical Alternatives To Current Education Models. My library is 30,000 books. There’s no John Grisham here. No Danielle Steel. I have 2,000 on the environment and 1,000 on war and violence and some peace, but there’s not much peace. I try to read 150 to200 books a year. I take 120 monthly magazines. I travel 300 days a year. If you don’t like things the way they are, then why not imagine you can change things?

How is your fundraising campaign going?

I haven’t had a moment’s discouragement in 40 years. That’s the power of a good idea. We have a $10 million fantasy. Were we to have a full operating hospital model, where staff and patients are happy to be there, feel how dangerous that would be.

We have an elective every October for medical students on humanism in medicine. We had them last year from Japan, Philippines, Brazil, Germany, England, U.S., Canada and Mexico. Even though we’re not seeing patients, they came to spend a month to learn about loving your patients. There’s a hunger in the world for something other than the worship of money and power. We’re trying to live a life filled with compassion. To my knowledge we are the only hospital model the world addressing all the problems of health care in one model—with all the healing arts, the eco village, no burnout.

Everything I read makes me believe we will be extinct this century. We are too fragile a species. We will not survive our misbehavior. We have sold out to the love of money. I will pay attention to sports when a schoolteacher makes more than an athlete. We need a value system based on compassion and generosity. We need a massive revolution of loving—which is superficially tweaked when we have a disaster like Haiti. Image how embarrassing it is for me when people think the Hollywood movie is what I’m about.

I haven’t seen it. Should I?

I was embarrassed for the movie, and I’ve come to love it for its impact. I get thousands of letters saying the movie made me go into medicine or decide to help humanity. People are so hungry for love and compassion. So for that reason, maybe you should see it.

Start your week smarter with our weekly e-mail newsletter. It's your cheat sheet for good ideas. Get it.

Melanie D.G. Kaplan

About Melanie D.G. Kaplan

Melanie D.G. Kaplan is a contributing writer for SmartPlanet.

Melanie D.G. Kaplan

Melanie D.G. Kaplan

Contributing Writer

Melanie D.G. Kaplan is a regular contributor to The Washington Post and WebMD and has written for The New York Times, National Geographic Traveler and People. She holds degrees from Syracuse University and Columbia University's Graduate School of Journalism. She is based in Washington, D.C.

Follow her on Twitter.

Melanie D.G. Kaplan

Melanie D.G. Kaplan

In addition to working as a journalist, Melanie keeps the dog food fund flush with occasional consulting jobs. In the unusual event that her writing mentions a company or organization for which she has provided editorial services, she will disclose that fact. She will do the same should she cover any companies in which she holds investments.

She writes for SmartPlanet and is not an employee of CBS.

If you liked this, don't miss...
26
Comments

Join the conversation!

Follow via:
RSS
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
The Soviet Union failed in large part because the nation rotted from the inside out. Most of Soviet society was corrupt, people just looked out for themselves and the systems that did work within that society were driven by intimidation. The idea of a credit card was totally an alien concept in the Soviet Union not so much because it represented capitalism, but because no one could be trusted to pay off the bill.

Love is America's secret weapon, we need more love.
Posted by cfaranetta
16th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
Ok, but somebody explain to me how any Dr. or anyone, for that matter can live on $300.00 a month.
Posted by lplaud@...
16th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
Cfarraette

I don?t quite understand the connection with Dr. Adams and the Soviet Union. But the amount of propaganda out there is overwhelming at times -- and in an America we sell our wars with the same vigor as we sell out toothpaste it is understandable. The Soviet Union was certainly a huge Bureaucracy but much of the corruption that allowed for the rebranding of the Soviet Union into Russia was related to a quasi-secret program ran by the United State over a ten year period. This program intent on economic sabotage of an already weakened Soviet economy.

During that time a large number of Soviet Citizens were ?bought? ? paid well -- to make sure the milk trucks didn?t run and the collective farms were inefficient and so on. This project and the rest of the cold war expenditure during those ten years was a little shy of $200 trillion dollars. The fact that the government is still trying to get this money on the books somehow is playing a major part in the current collapse of the US economy. So here is where karma plays her role ? what was economic sabotage for the Soviet Union has turned into economic suicide for the US economy.

What could Patch do with $200 trillion dollars?

Just divide that amount by the current US population and you will see there would be more enough to pay for a lifetime of health care and a collage education for each and every American citizen.

But on the bright side -- it was a small price to pay to prevent total destruction of the earth?s bioshere in a MAD thermonuclear war. At least we can rebuild from an economic Armageddon ? not the same can be said about a thermonuclear war.
Posted by VTRIX
16th Feb 2010
-1 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
any surgeon who will work for $300 / month , no matter how much joy and silliness abound, i would not let even examine me, let alone do any cutting.

where does this guy get these utopian ideas that he believes will work.

i think it is time fora little bah humbug in his life
Posted by stilt21
16th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
Wow
Wow, you are a very close minded person. With the health problems I have I can understand better than you. There are good people out there that care more about people than money. You obviously aren't one of them. I have seen many doctors bc I have many illnesses. I have not found one that I like because they are "pricks" like he says tone of the guys in the movie. I want a doctor that cares about my feelings and wants me to have a better quality of life. I have not found one that is like that. How close minded of you and shame on you!!!!!!!
Posted by emiller85
7th May
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
Read the book "True Freedom - The Road to the First Real Democracy" (I found it on www.democraticroad.com) if you want to learn of the proper way to create a more equitable and affordable health care system for the majority of Americans. The wealthy can still have their personal high cost system which they will pay for and not you.
Posted by dgage19558@...
16th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
What we WANT to believe (and may publicly espouse) and what we REALLY believe are often in conflict. If I were injured while travelling, I want to say I would readily go under the knife of a 36K per year surgeon at a rural community hospital. The reality is that I always know where the nearest trauma center is and would probably demand to be taken there.
Posted by langedd@...
16th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
I think a doctor and cleaning person work for the same money. For example,it takes about 10 years to become an MD. Assuming a cleaning person gets paid $10 per hour, the amount of money the doctor has "missed" earning as a result of time spent on education (while there is no education required to be a cleaning person you can pretty much start cleaning houses as soon as you turn 18), is 160 hours per week x 12 (months) x 10 years x $10 = $200,000 add to that the cost of education $300000. Total comes to $500,000. Using a standard investment calculator, that amount is worth $2 million over a 10 year period with interest rate of 10%. So a doctor earning about $150,000 a year would work 15 years just to get even with a cleaning person. Simple math.
Posted by Smart Cookie
16th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
Anyone that wants free health care can go to Patch Adams
hospital system and get there care there. Its a perfect solution!
Your surgeon will be homeless (at $300 per month) and so will
everyone else there. That will take care of our uninsured problem.
Anyone that doesn't want to work can go to the Patch Adams
healthcare system. Problem solved. Call Obama now, let
congress know right away. I'll vote for it.
Posted by OrthoDoc34
16th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
Fantastic theory if only it could be done world wide in practice. A client of mine is a very nice very rich old man who has cancer If he was not able to go to Switzerland to have an operation immediately he would be dead. still on chemotherapy in London at best hospital the problem is how do you choose who to save if the resources are limited the old person who has worked all their life or the young person with all to live for? the answer will always be regretfully but correctly the one that can pay for it otherwise there would be no resources as the older people would see no point in paying for something they might need but will never get. I cant afford it but pay for the best heath insurance as I am getting old...
Posted by ronangel
16th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
Free health care facilities will be rapidly inundated with obese, diabetic, addicted, stupid, self indulgent fools with no room for the rest. Who will shoot the lawyers who would represent them as they sue for more and better free care? We are animals first and possibly human later. Patch is OK for true humans in a limited way but as long as we spend more on music, bottled water, professional sports or pet food than on thinking and learning, Patch's plan is not implementable.
Posted by fw32
16th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
We all could do with a dose of "love thy neighbor" but Dr Adams seems to be living off of the gifts of others who earn more than $300 a minute. How many of his hundreds of books did he buy? How many books could be writen or printed if the author and printer earned only $300 a month? His kind of philosophy can only be supported when those who make $300 a minute are willing to share not by asking everyone to live on $300 a month. That is like saying if everyone had an IQ of 75 there would be fewer dumb people.
Posted by Popsprice
17th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Socialism and the Soviet Union
If we're done re-writing history here, let's look at why the Soviet Union really failed and why Patch Adams ideas, while nice-sounding, are flawed too. The Soviet Union failed because, ultimately people want to reap the rewards of their own hard work. If I can do a job twice as good as you, I expect to be better compensated. It's what keeps me motivated to do a good job. In the Soviet Union, people quickly figured out that no matter how hard they worked, they'd always get paid the same. When they realized this, they only worked as hard as they had to to get by, and productivity fell off a cliff. Of course, it also didn't help that the Communist Party was hoarding all the nations resources for themselves, but that's another story. That's why universal healthcare will fail too. Because, people today who get into medicine, sign up for a career in which they will have to spend 6 to 10 years getting educated at a cost of 150-300 thousand dollars with an expectation that on the backend they'll make a significantly better income than if they learned a trade or went into a white collar job. With socialized medicine, you take away that earning power. Now the best and brightest don't want to go into medicine as often, because the payoff isn't there. Suddenly, you're stuck with people in medicine who were B and C students in school and wondering why your care is suffering. Plus, the government is in charge of paying for everything, and there's only so much money to go around, so now the rationing begins. It's already happening in other countries with socialized medicine. Decisions are being made as to who gets life-saving treatments and who doesn't based of their value to society. Not to mention the fact that the waiting lists are so long that people with diseases like cancer might get approved for treatment, but by the time they get treated, it's already to late and the disease has progressed from treatable to terminal. But hey, with Patch's system at least they'll get all the hugs they want when they're dying. I'm sure that will make up for not getting that treatment in time.

As for this conspiracy theory up above where the US spent 200 trillion dollars to overthrow the Soviet Union, who exactly bankrolled that? The Illuminati, the Lizardmen? Socialism collapsed under its own weight of inefficiency coupled with the fact that it is a system that contradicts man's nature. The only quasi-secret war the US fought with the USSR was the arms race, and yes, we spent them into the ground, but not because of clandestine operations, but simply the fact that the Soviet economy could never outpace capitalism over the long haul. There was also that whole freedom thing that the Russians started to want, but I guess they were just being selfish fools, huh?
Posted by branchman67
17th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
it brings tears to my eyes when i read about the compassion in this man Patch Adams....why can't it happen? we are not living in a democracy if we can't find the way to help people by curing their diseases, loneliness and malfunctioning minds....
Posted by drazil43
17th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
cfaranetta
You are exactly right about the need for love. We already have plenty of cynicism.

Iplaud
It is possible to live on $300 a month here in Montana. Of course you must have some other skills. But for basics, $300 will do.

VTrix
What an interesting bit of history. I would love to see your sources for such strong statements. Would you please post a few of your references?

Dear Stilt21
Money is not the measure of qualification. Anyone with a modicum of intelligence can become a doctor. It takes a gifted person to become a healer. And dedicated to human welfare. Most American doctors are mere technicians presently, without real diagnostic skills. They depend upon chemistry from some lab with which they have no personal knowledge and upon hi-tech devices that are objective, yes, but totally without understanding or imagination. "Money can't buy back your youth, but laughter can make old age quite enjoyable." --Vox 'Zard
Posted by alb3125@...
17th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
Let's be realistic.
Come on!! $300 is not enough if you want a family and pay off for your college education. Are doctors expected to be monks and nuns? Why does "free" always have to link with "socialist commies"? Most European countries have adequate free health care regardless of if a CENTER left or CENTER right government is in power. If you have a suitable tax collection mechanism there is no reason for it not to work. Basically the US will never have free health care because the insurance industry will be out of a job.
Posted by jsargent
17th Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
VTRIX says, ". . the amount of propaganda out there is overwhelming at times" and then spews some of the most ridiculous propaganda I've ever seen! happy The Soviet Union failed because the leadership finally realized that their system had fallen far behind the West and, as it was, would just continue to fall further behind.

As to the current US health care system, Republicans and Democrats agree that the cost trend lines are unsustainable. In other words, without change, the current health care system will implode. Contrary to the current popular propaganda, Canada and the "EU" have made the choices necessary to address the problems the US is facing and their health care systems are providing better overall results than ours. Meanwhile, we're insisting on a perfect health care system that costs us little (costs are already higher than the aforementioned ?socialized? health care systems); it's "pick one" not "pick both". Congress seems to be full of "followers" and we disparately need "leaders".
Posted by GarryGR
22nd Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
I think a lot of people on this post seem to be missing the point. No one is claiming that a doctor's services are only worth $300 a month. Nor does it seem that a Patch Adams' type hospital model is meant to replace our current system en masse. That a hospital like Adams' can exist is telling: doctors who could make much more money elsewhere are willing to work on a nearly volunteer basis. Simple put, they wouldn't be choosing to do this if the non-monetary payoffs (work environment, pride in work, fulfillment) didn't outweigh the cost (reduction in pay). So as opposed to dismissing Adams' idea as impractical, we should think about how to bring more compassion into the current system.
Posted by jd006h
23rd Feb 2010
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
I an a bachelor. I am 52 years old. I like older people because I miss my own older relatives who have died. In the last 12 years I have run my own business and taken care of two ninety year old people whom where total strangers to me. One died and we buried him and now I am left with my friend Sara who has had a broken hip. I change her diapers and run errands for her. I wonder where her kin must be. I wonder what the world has against older people because to me, older people are just like me. They are human beings and I have learned the hard way that taking good care one is better than fame and fortune.
Posted by ZuluZ5
31st Mar 2011
0 Votes
+ -
good
Where does Idaho rank? We have been living in Montana for the past 5 years and I am not supri sexy shop to find it #3 on the "worst" list. Considering a sexshopmove to Idaho to escapthe high cost of living a low income in MT. There may not be a sales tax here but they get you if you own property!
Posted by jeffmgf
19th Jul 2011
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
paraben sex shops por mais esse post
Posted by vipsexshop
14th Apr 2011
0 Votes
+ -
Patch Adams continues fighting for joyful, loving health care
paraben power balances por mais esse post
Posted by osoz
30th Apr 2011
0 Votes
+ -
where are patch adams hospitals located???
If anyone can assist me, it would be greatly appreciated
Posted by pzipkin
Updated - 4th Jul 2011
0 Votes
+ -
bom
Where does Idaho rank? We have been living in Montana for the past 5 years and I am not supri sexy shop to find it #3 on the "worst" list. Considering a sexshopmove to Idaho to escapthe high cost of living a low income in MT. There may not be a sales tax here but they get you if you own property!
Posted by jeffmgf
19th Jul 2011
0 Votes
+ -
More crazy
To bad his hospitals aren't themed like
mary poppins because it might make the little kids happier.
Posted by harry39458
Updated - 7th Aug 2011
0 Votes
+ -
Crazy!
An a bachelor. I am 52 years old. I like o putarialder people because I miss my own older relatives who have died. In the last 12 years I have run my own business and taken care of two ninety year old people whom where total strangers to me.
Posted by thomasjeff
16th Sep 2011
Join the conversation
Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]

Join the SmartPlanet community and join the conversation! Signing up is fast and free. Don't wait -- we want to hear your opinion!