Follow this blog:
RSS

Moving documentary of 9/11 evacuation by boat shows resilience of cities

By | September 8, 2011, 7:31 AM PDT

Here, in its entirety, is the incredibly moving, just-released, Tom Hanks-narrated, 11-minute documentary of the largest-ever evacuation by boat in history.

In nine hours, boats streaming in from all over the Northeast evacuated 500,000 people trapped on Manhattan Island by the complete shutdown of all trains and bridges in the wake of the fall of the twin towers. (Compare that with history’s second-biggest evacuation, of 339,000 soldiers and civilians from Dunkirk, in WWII, which took nine days.)

One of the things this event illustrates is that in cities present and future, redundancy is one of the keys to resilience. New York has long neglected its waterfront, and in the face of rising seas it is even occasionally seen as a liability. And yet without access to the water, a half million New Yorkers would not have made it home on 9/11.

This documentary was produced by Road2Resilience, part of an effort by the Center for National Policy to “build the reflexes and instincts necessary at every level of American society to respond quickly and wisely to future crises.”

Start your week smarter with our weekly e-mail newsletter. It's your cheat sheet for good ideas. Get it.

Christopher Mims

About Christopher Mims

Christopher Mims was a contributing editor for SmartPlanet from 2011 to 2012.

Christopher Mims

Christopher Mims

Contributing Editor

Christopher Mims has written for Scientific American, WIRED, Popular Science, Fast Company, Good, Discover, Slate, Technology Review, Nature and the Nicholas Institute for Environmental Policy Solutions at Duke University. Formerly, he was an editor at Scientific American, Grist and Seed. He is based in Washington, D.C.

Follow him on Twitter.

Christopher Mims

Christopher Mims

Christopher does not have financial holdings that would influence how or what he covers.

He writes for SmartPlanet and is not an employee of CBS.

If you liked this, don't miss...
26
Comments

Join the conversation!

Follow via:
RSS
-1 Votes
+ -
Quibble with intro text
Begging your pardon, not having watched the video yet, but I have a quibble with the text here: I wonder whether all the people in Manhattan who streamed across the bridges on foot to get home on 9/11 knew that they were supposed to be "trapped" because of the "complete shutdown of all...bridges." Either my memory and a number of photographs published later are wrong or there's a bit of exaggeration in this text.
Posted by JEB54
8th Sep 2011
+2 Votes
+ -
trapped
I think it depended upon which side, North or South, of the towers you were, if you could make it to a bridge. For those South, there was no way off the island. I don't think it would have been possible to walk North through the carnage to get to the Brooklyn Bridge entrances.
Posted by dwhite0849
8th Sep 2011
0 Votes
+ -
Disagreement
If by "carnage" (which strictly means "the killing of a large number of people") you wanted to suggest rubble and debris, I disagree. WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 collapsed onto themselves, with partial damage to surrounding buildings such as the Deutsche Bank Building. There was no carnage and no rubble anywhere else. There was for a while a slowly settling and noxious cloud of dust. That was followed by an ugly dark plume of smoke that rose as it drifted southeast. Those were only temporary impediments.

It was and is entirely possible to walk to the Brooklyn Bridge, to use the example you mentioned, from Battery Park City, very near the WTC site but to its west, or from anywhere else nearer the bridge, by going south to the pedestrian/cycling path and following it around the water's edge to the bridge. (More direct routes were available too.) I lived below 14th Street at the time, and I did and still do work in Midtown. I've asked a number of my friends and colleagues, who you can be sure are pretty well acquainted with the events of 9/11, how anyone could've been "trapped" in Lower Manhattan. No one understands it. Being unable to walk very far counts for something; being unwilling to go through the cloud counts, but it didn't last all day. Guesses about what "would have been possible" may be reasonable, but they don't stand up against knowledge of the area.
Posted by JEB54
2nd Oct 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
Carnage
this is a term that is not being used correctly but it does fit, were you there at ground zero seeing the people jump and fall to there deaths and then know the number that will never be found, it is the correct term. think if they took bodies and placed them on the streets with bloddy sheets on them for all of the people the were really lost, then what woul you have to say then, the term was correct. These people were killed by others and they did nothing wrong, yes it was CARNAGE!
Posted by wayne.dean
3rd Oct 2011
+3 Votes
+ -
Quibble with intro text
Who cares? What's important is that almost 500,000 people weren't more victims. This is an American story, full of heros. I've always said when you attack our country, we ALL become soldiers for good!
Posted by Shugdj
16th Sep 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
comparison
The comparison of the 9/11 evacuation and Dunkirk is ludicrous and demeaning. As horrific as 9/11 was, the Brits on the sands of Dunkirk were being strafed by the Luftwaffe, many were wounded, food was non-existent, and all had been in war for months, and were rescued by an armada of 850 boats and ships, ranging from naval transports to a 15' shore trawler. Evacuation for many involved wading out into water at shoulder height and waiting for hours to be scooped up by small boats to be ferried to the big ships or taken all the way to the English coast, often under fire from the German Army.
Posted by DARdeviate
12th Sep 2011
+2 Votes
+ -
You missed the point
Though I agree that the two events were different on many levels, the point this documentary is making is how 1) the 911 boatlift, unlike Dunkirk, was not a planned, orchestrated endeavor that was being directed by any agency or government, but was conducted by ordinary American citizens with great character, patriotism and sense of duty who saw a need and selflessly filled it; and, 2) that 500,000 people were evacuated in a mere 9 hours, as opposed to the nine days it took to evacuate the troops. Were the circumstances different? Yes. But does that make the achievement any less miraculous? No. As for the troops at Dunkirk being under attack during their evacuation - New York was under attack, and no one knew if it was over. Though there wasn't another attack that day in New York, there certainly was no way to know that that would be the case. And so, every person who ran into a building, ran towards the towers, or sailed towards New York to help their fellow Americans, is a hero.
Posted by jbkp54
Updated - 19th Sep 2011
+2 Votes
+ -
Not exactly like for like in a real war situation but still very moving.
Everyone should sit down for 9 minutes and watch this incredible documentary. Few are even aware it happened. Well worth watching...takes a few minutes but it's good.
Just like the Dunkirk spirit as the caption says except that the Germans had 136 frontline Divisions, 3,600 tanks and 3,000 aircraft outside the thinly defended British perimeter and the brave boys defending that perimeter either died or went into the cage for nearly 6 long years ??? no escape for them. For every seven soldiers who escaped through Dunkirk, one man was left behind as a POW or worse. The Royal Navy lost 9 destroyers and over 200 little ships many of them fully loaded with men in the middle of the English Channel, 19 destroyers were very badly damaged and the Royal Air Force lost 959 planes of all types.

So not exactly like for like in a real war situation but still a very moving human story truly invoking the Dunkirk spirit and selfless sacrifice ??? well done America.

I was unaware of this action......this will take 9 minutes out of your day, and restore your faith in America....and make you cry...........JGM
Posted by j.monaghan@...
12th Sep 2011
+2 Votes
+ -
All Americans are heroes at heart
This is just one more example of the American spirit at work. The terrorists thought that they would tear our country apart and all they did was make us join together. Every time there is any type of disaster the American people rise to the occasion and help each other. You saw it in the towers with people helping friends and strangers escape, you saw it at the Pentagon with men returning to the building over and over to pull more people out, you saw it in Shanksville where the passengers knew by that time that they were destined to crash into another building. They knew the plan of the hijackers and crashed the plane into a field, giving up their lives to save countless other lives of Americans that they did not even know. That's what Americans do. They stand up proud and strong and together and face adversity with resolve. I am proud to be an American and these boatmen did not have to give up their time and possibly their lives as no one knew if another attack was coming. They just did it. They heard the call and they responded without a second thought. These negative comments are ignorant and wrong. Take pride in your country, yourself, and be proud to be an American.
Posted by ddbl133
13th Sep 2011
+2 Votes
+ -
9/11 boats helping evacuees
Yes, this is a nation of mostly Patriotic, loving people who unite in dangerous and overwhelming rescues. wars, and help of all kinds. No matter what, true Americans will help for emergencies, an accident or even the Twin Towers terrrorist attack. People give up their lives to fight, or help and I am so proud to be an American when I see things like this it brings tears to my eyes. Of sadness and happiness all at the same time. We love this country and we always will be there to protect it from evil.

God Bless America....the land of the free. Forever
Posted by shadowdancer_ap
Updated - 30th Sep 2011
+2 Votes
+ -
America's Best
This is our country at its best. Heroes all. God bless every one of these men.
Posted by Bar X Horse Ranch
13th Sep 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
Boat Rescue 911
Has this Documentary been shown nationally? If not Y? I must have forgotten this.
Americans are made of such goodness on the whole, only a few bad apples too often
are profiled. God Bless us all. So many quiet heros are among us.
Posted by DonnaDMe
14th Sep 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
The Boat Lift On 9/11.
I Want The People Of The 9/11 Boat Lift To Know I Am Very Sorry For Not Knowing About It Before Now. All Of you Are As Great As The Fire Personnel, The Police Personnel And Every One On That Day That Helped The People Of New York. I Hope The People Of This Country Never Forget. We Are Still The Greatest Nation!
Posted by Bullrunner58
16th Sep 2011
+2 Votes
+ -
9/11 boats save 500,000 people
I had no idea that this took place...500,000 in about 9 hours. Amazing how many things we find out 10 years later...some sooner...but, these people would have never made it out of their if it wasn't for these brave Captains/boat owners and for all the tug boats to come to the rescue, totally amazing and BRAVE....each and everyone that saved lives, or lost their lives, or were brought together during this time, WE ALL STILL STAND PROUD AND FREE and nothing, nothing will bring us down, it will only make us STRONGER, ONE NATION UNDER GOD! AND LET 'FREEDOM RING' LOUD AND CLEAR...GOD BLESS AMERICA and I am proud to be an AMERICAN!
Posted by annialex@...
16th Sep 2011
+2 Votes
+ -
9/11 boats save half a million people in less than 9 hours
The Americans are here. We help every Country on the planet but don't look for other Countries to come to our rescue. Americans help each other. That's what freedom does. God bless each and every one who helped on that day. We will never forget.
Posted by onlylu
17th Sep 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
A Proud Story! Thank you!
I believe this shows how - We as Americans are truely a great people! The rescue was unplanned and came together simply by the will power of the people! Great job, and thank you for sharing...I never knew this side of the story- I cried, and felt proud of them and proud for them!! Thank you!! Julie from Michigan!
Posted by great911jules@...
21st Sep 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
Proud to Be an American
I have always been proud to be an American. After watching this story and seeing how Americans comes together in a situation as this and putting the safety of their own lives aside just shows how much we love our Country and will always come together as one and I am even more proud to be an American. Had I been there on this date, I would have done the exact same thing. I am very proud of these people. America is one big family and you don't mess with family. Excellent job family! I love you all!
Posted by talktopaulette
22nd Sep 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
Boat lift 9/11
WOW, this is awesome. I had no clue that this even happened. It should be shown on TV, so more people know what else went on that day. So many hero's, not enough praise !!
Posted by lindaleeee
24th Sep 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
Awesome!
Who among us will ask why, by withholding heroic and prideful stories like this, the media keeps a partriotic groundswell subdued? The media (and politicians) could earn needed respect by reporting this and other great deeds of courage, brotherhood and duty even now more than ten years after the fact and at a time when respect, courage and patriotism are needed as much or more than any other time in history. I'm just sayin'...
Posted by Dog man 1
Updated - 25th Sep 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
Boat lift 9/11,,,
This just confirms what I have known for years, when Americans are in trouble, they act,
that is why no nation will try and invade American soil, they know our first right to bare "ARMS", the only nation was England, and we ALL know how that turned out. Americans stick together no matter what happens, they do it out because they can, not because they were told to. Other nations do not have our "AMENDMENTS", this in turn will make other nations think twice about messing with,
"THE UNITED STATES of AMERICA"

Mark B.
Posted by moinkb2004@...
26th Sep 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
9/11 Boat Evacuation
I love my people! My people, my people; I love my people. See how you are? It's a good country!
Posted by mdreser
26th Sep 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
The Great Boat Evacuation
Americans are the greatest people on earth.... and New York City is the greatest city on earth!!! God Bless America!
Posted by papaderf
28th Sep 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
Half a million? Really?
I question the 500,000 figure, because the film gives no clue where it comes from. According to a New York State study prepared in 2007 (available at www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/pdf/census/pre_post_911.pdf), 386,000 people worked in Lower Manhattan in 2000, and about 34,700 lived there in 2000. That equals 420,700. No doubt tourists were present too, though I wonder whether there were 79,000 of them. So there may not have been half a million people in the area to begin with, depending on how you define it, and not all of them left by boat. See why I doubt the figure given in the film?

You can recognize the nobility of the boat crews' efforts while disagreeing with many details about the impressions this film gives. To me it's misleading, and in a way that does a disservice to everyone involved, because it undermines the whole video. Why do we have to put a questionable number on those stranded and claim the boatlift surpassed Dunkirk before we can say people did an honorable and admirable thing?
Posted by JEB54
2nd Oct 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
events of 9/11/01
something that you all must remember is that most of those that were trapped were not from that area, and road in on the subway or on the buses of the city or others means of transportation. That was now not able to run as the suway system had been blocked and the streets were blocked and almost anything else was blocked as WE ALL STOOD BY AND WATCHED! These people were getting out any way they could and if someone told me the bridges were closed i would not try to cross them and most people would never even try to walk that far even to start with as we Americans are use to our cars and other ways of getting around and to walk is too much for many. So yes i can understand if it were 500,000 that were taken accross the river and if not who cares as it was still a great feat in itself. It was not as great as Dunkurk was in WW2, as i dont think many of the boats would have been running had jets been trying to take them out as the Germany Airforce as trying to do the the British. This was still a great feat, so you that are winning about just shut up as we all know those in power are always going to over estamate the numbers just to make it look bigger than it really was.
Posted by wayne.dean
3rd Oct 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
surrender
I'm choked up!
I can not abide surrendering to the Muslim enemy by allowing them to build a Masque on this site. It is not a place of worship as we normally think of it, but a symbol of occupation and dominance.
Posted by pillsnpwd@...
10th Oct 2011
+1 Vote
+ -
The sprawl problem comes
The sprawl problem comes from people wanting to get out of the problem 'inner' city area. The problem is limited by the maximum trip time that people will put up with. Robot (computer) driven cars are not faster than human driven cars, so the trip time will not be substantially reduced. It will probably take longer. What it may do is to reduce the number of cars you need. If the car can take me to the train station, then go back home, It could serve double duty. If my family needs two cars, it's just a matter of scheduling kral oyun kanal d oyun
Posted by onur26
Updated - 13th Oct 2011
Join the conversation
Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]

Join the SmartPlanet community and join the conversation! Signing up is fast and free. Don't wait -- we want to hear your opinion!